PLA vs PETG vs resin vs nylon: which to order
Most people ordering a print don't need to know polymer chemistry. They need to know which material survives their use case without paying for more than they need. This is that guide, in the order makers actually think about it.
Start from the use, not the material
Before you pick a material, answer three questions:
- Does it carry load, or just sit there?
- Does it see heat, sun or water?
- Does it need fine detail or a smooth surface?
Nearly every part is a "yes" to at most one of these, and that one answer picks the material.
PLA: the default
The lowest-priced option, easiest to print, and available in the most colors. Stiff, decent detail, fine indoors. Weak points: it softens around 55–60 °C (a car dashboard in July will warp it) and it's brittle under repeated stress.
Order PLA for: display pieces, prototypes to check fit, jigs that live on a bench, phone stands, organizers, anything that doesn't get hot or bent.
Price pressure: the floor. Everything else is compared to it.
PETG: the functional default
A bit more expensive than PLA, noticeably tougher, handles about 75–80 °C, doesn't mind water or UV nearly as much. Surface is slightly glossier and layer lines show a little more. This is what most makers reach for when a part has to work.
Order PETG for: brackets, clips, enclosures, outdoor mounts, replacement parts on appliances, anything that gets clipped in and out.
Price pressure: slightly above PLA.
ABS and ASA: heat and sun
ABS is the old workhorse: takes 90–100 °C, sands and solvent-smooths well. ASA is ABS's outdoor cousin with far better UV resistance. Both need an enclosed printer, so fewer makers offer them and bids sit a little higher.
Order ABS/ASA for: parts near engines or hot electronics, anything left in direct sun for years, parts you want acetone-smoothed.
Price pressure: above PETG, mostly because fewer shops can print it.
Nylon and carbon fiber: load
FDM nylon is tough and slightly flexible; it takes impact and abrasion that would crack PETG. Carbon-fiber-filled nylon is stiffer and holds dimensions better. Both are harder to print and more expensive, and plain nylon absorbs moisture, which the maker manages.
Order nylon/CF for: gears, hinges, snap fits that cycle thousands of times, drone frames, tool handles, load-bearing brackets.
Price pressure: well above PLA and PETG.
Resin: detail
Resin printing (SLA/MSLA) cures liquid resin with light, layer by layer, at resolutions FDM can't touch. Surfaces are smooth, details are crisp, and 28 mm miniatures come out with faces. Standard resin is brittle, though: it chips if dropped and creeps under load. Engineering resins fix some of that at a higher price.
Order resin for: miniatures, figures, jewelry masters, dental and detail-heavy models, anything you'll paint and display.
Price pressure: above the filament plastics; wash, cure and support cleanup add handling.
SLS nylon: production
Selective laser sintering fuses nylon powder with no supports at all, so parts are strong in every direction and have a fine, matte, slightly grainy surface. It's the material of choice for parts that need to look and behave like injection molding without the tooling. Fewer makers run SLS and the minimums are higher.
Order SLS for: functional prototypes headed for production, complex geometries with internal channels, small batches of end-use parts.
Price pressure: the highest of the group.
The short version
| Need | Order | Price pressure |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest, indoor, display | PLA | Lowest |
| Functional, everyday, outdoors | PETG | Slightly up |
| Heat or long-term sun | ABS / ASA | Up |
| Load, impact, wear | Nylon / carbon fiber | Up a lot |
| Fine detail, smooth surface | Resin | Up |
| Production-grade, no support marks | SLS nylon | Highest |
Which 3D printing material for my part? PLA to SLS nylon
Most material guides are written for people choosing filament for their own printer. They spend paragraphs on nozzle temperatures and bed adhesion. When you're ordering a part, none of that is your problem. Your question is simpler: what does my part have to survive?
Start there and the choice is usually obvious.
Pick by the job
| If your part... | Start with | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Is decorative, a prototype or a model, indoors | PLA | Easy to print, crisp detail, many colours. "Not suitable for technical and outdoor use" (Prusa) |
| Is a functional bracket, clip, holder or enclosure | PETG | Tough, good layer adhesion, suits use "below 80 °C" (Prusa) |
| Lives outdoors or in a car | ASA | "More UV resistant" than ABS, "up to 93 °C" (Prusa) |
| Takes impacts, needs acetone smoothing or gluing | ABS | "High tenacity & mechanical resistance", but yellows outdoors (Prusa) |
| Must bend, squash or grip | TPU | Flexible, wear and chemical resistant, "stay flexible even in cold environments" (Prusa) |
| Is a gear, hinge or wear part | Nylon | "Resistant to abrasion", "low coefficient of friction" (Prusa) |
| Needs fine detail and a smooth surface | Resin | Layers from 25 to 100 microns, near-moulded surface (Hubs) |
| Is a complex functional part, or many of them | SLS nylon (PA12) | No supports needed; properties Formlabs compares to injection moulding (Formlabs) |
Heat figures above are from Prusa's guides for its own filaments. Other brands differ. Treat them as rough ceilings, not ratings.
Three special cases
Food contact. Prusa says PLA and PETG are considered food-safe as raw materials, but recommends against printing anything that touches food directly, because the layer grooves can harbour bacteria (Prusa). Formlabs adds that food-safe parts need materials meeting FDA 21 CFR or EU 10/2011 (Formlabs). Ask the maker specifically.
Hot environments. Engine bays, ovens, kettles, heaters: if it gets close to or above the limits in the table, a common printed plastic is the wrong material. Ask about engineering materials, or don't print it.
Safety-critical parts. Don't let material choice talk you into printing a part whose failure can hurt someone.
If you're still not sure
Don't guess. Describe what the part does, where it lives and what it attaches to, and pick "Not sure" for material when you post. Makers will recommend in their bids, and you'll often get two suggestions with two prices, which is exactly the comparison you want. What else moves a quote is in the price guide; when you're ready, post the part.
FAQ
What's the strongest 3D printing material? Of the common ones, nylon and SLS nylon are the toughest for functional parts. PETG is the practical middle ground. "Strongest" depends on whether you mean impact, stiffness, wear or heat.
What's the best material for outdoor parts? ASA. Prusa rates it UV resistant. PLA and ABS degrade in sunlight.
Which material gives the most detail? Resin. For tough, detailed functional parts, SLS nylon.
Is PLA strong enough? For decorative items, prototypes and light-duty indoor parts, yes. For anything warm, outdoors or under real load, step up to PETG or ASA.
Describe the job, not the plastic, and post your part free. Makers will propose materials in their bids.